A thing that might have flummoxed every one is that whether Snape is a murderer and guilty of treachery to ALBUS PERCIVAL WULFRIC BRIAN DUMBLEDORE.I believe not.
I believe that Snape is betraying YOU-KNOW-WHO.For proving my point I would like to point at some instances from the books
1.Hagrid tells the three friends that SNAPE was overworked and told DUMBLEDORE that he expected too much from him .Surely Snape had returned to VOLDEMORT but as Dumbledore’s man
2. Snape is a superb OCCLUMENS.So why couldn’t he have hood winked Voldemort
3. While telling Narcissa why does he close the curtains and looks away from her even though he was the only wizard there for miles.
May be he did not want to insult Narcissa by employing OCCLUMENCY against her. Even Bellatrix was a good Legilemans
SO the dice has been rolled. But I will not be surprised if the last piece of jigsaw turns the world upside down for all of us in the wizarding world.
cat snape
I believe that Snape is betraying YOU-KNOW-WHO.For proving my point I would like to point at some instances from the books
1.Hagrid tells the three friends that SNAPE was overworked and told DUMBLEDORE that he expected too much from him .Surely Snape had returned to VOLDEMORT but as Dumbledore’s man
2. Snape is a superb OCCLUMENS.So why couldn’t he have hood winked Voldemort
3. While telling Narcissa why does he close the curtains and looks away from her even though he was the only wizard there for miles.
May be he did not want to insult Narcissa by employing OCCLUMENCY against her. Even Bellatrix was a good Legilemans
SO the dice has been rolled. But I will not be surprised if the last piece of jigsaw turns the world upside down for all of us in the wizarding world.
cat snape
3 comments:
Bowman!
Well Written, my friend. Severus Snape is definetely a mysterious character to look upon. With such enormous potential (look the spells he invented in his sixth year), he is surely someone who can change things.
His deviation towards the dark arts, his reverence for big V, his pure blood mania, his claim to be responsible for the murder of Emmeline Vance, and his grudge towards the marauders and Harry sure makes his a dodgy character.
The fact that he murdered Albus Dumbledore in cold blood does not improve his image at all.
But the trust old D put in him for so many years and the way he intensely stood by his sede is something that cannot be ignored. It is not easy to gain old D's trust, even by Occlumency. Also, Snape values honour, otherwise why did he save Harry's life in PS, while he could have simply ignored it.
Such a personality surely deserves to be given a special title of Half Bloof Prince and put on the title cover of the 6th book!
The comments made by the two ladies above show two different sides of Snape. While Elladora does not seem too impressed with Snape (she has surely given good reason for that),on the other hand Cliodne paints a sensitive picture of Severus, and her theory about Snape having a crush on Lily is definetely thought provoking.
Snape has many layers, with his two-edged sword of occlumency, he is surely a double-double-double... (how many times?!) agent.
To Bowman...
My dear friend. I am happy that you have finally got your touch and the subject of ur theory was at bull's eye. But I would have enjoyed reading your theory if you had given strong and argumentative points and your theory could have counter-argued Elladora's attacks.
MY DEAREST ELLADORA,
1- YOU ASK ME WHY HE HAS RESPECT FOR DUMBLEDORE? FOR THE SAME REASON THAT OLD D HAS FOR VOLDEMORT AND VICE-VERSA. LET ME TELL YOU THAT EVEN THOUGH VOLDEMOTR IS WICKED BUT HE IS A GREAT WIZARD. FORGIVE ME FOR SAYING THIS BUT I THINK JUST A TOE AHEAD OF EVEN DUMBLEDORE.SNAPE HAS PREVIOUSLY EVEN BEEN AT HIS SERVICE AND AS D HIMSELF SAID WOUNDS NEVER COMPLETELY HEAL
2-SNAPE HANDED THE PROPHECY WHEN HE WAS IN SERVICE TO VOLDEMORT
3- YOUR SECOND POINT THOUGH IS SURELY STRONG AND I AM NOT IN A POSITION TO ANSWER THEM RIGHT NOW
CLIODNE!
WHAT A FANTASTIC OBSERVATION. YOU DESERVE FULL CREDIT MY FRIEND. I WOULD LIKE TO SUPPORT YOUR THEORY SAYING THAT SNAPE RETURNED TO OUR SIDE NOT BECAUSE HIS INFORMATION MADE JAMES DIE BUT LILY DIE!
THOUGH WHY DOES HE INSULT HER BY CALLING HER MUDBLOOD IF HE WAS TRULY IN LOVE WITH HER?
Post a Comment